Applade Ryalle – A Medieval Apple Soup Three Ways (Harleian MS. 279, c.1430)

.Cxxxv. Applade Ryalle — Prepared for Nede, Flesshe Day, and Fysshe Day

Today's adventure in cooking from Two fifteenth-century cookery-books : Harleian MS. 279 (ab 1430) was Applade Ryalle, loosely interpreted as "Royal Apple" or "Apple Royal." It includes instructions for producing three vastly different flavored soups using the same base. The soups are made with beef broth (for a flesh day), almond milk (for a fish day), and "in need" with a broth made of wine and honey. The base of the soup is quite simple: apples that have been boiled until tender (read: falling apart) and then strained through a strainer.

🍽️ Where Could This Be Served at Feast?

Option	Reasoning	Notes
🥣 First Remove (Pottage)	Classic sweet pottage with period consistency and spice blend	Ideal with bread or savory pies
🍷 Welcome Drink	The wine/honey version mimics a warm cordial or broth	Serve in mugs or small bowls
🍽️ Entrée Companion	Adds contrast to roasted meats or cheese boards	Best served thicker, like a sauce

I made all three of the soups today and the taste testers (God bless them) tried each of them. We all agreed that the soup "in need" and the soup for a fish day were the better of the recipes. The house smelled like fall, with the ginger, cinnamon, apples, and wine scenting the air. Of the apple recipes I have interpreted, this is by far my favorite. Creating a variety of soups fit for a king! Huzzah!

The Applade Ryalle for a flesh (meat) day was pleasant, and if I had cooked just this I think the testers' opinions would have been a bit different. I, being unsure if I would like it, cooked it last—my mistake. The flavor of the apples was sharpened by the beef broth, so that I was reminded of eating a sour apple candy (which I like). This soup was good, but all of us decided that this might fall under the category of "too period to serve." Don't get me wrong—it was flavorful, and you should try it. However, the taste won't be for everyone, and the testers were put off by the smell of the apples and beef broth. Once they ate the first spoonful, it was a race to see who finished first.

The Applade Ryalle for a fish day received rave reviews. The soup was creamy and mild and delicious. What most of the taste testers remarked on first was that they could taste the spices used, and that the almond milk enhanced that, and then they tasted a hint of the apple and a hint of the almonds. It was really good and has made it onto my list of things to serve more often in the house. Yes, it will become something I will serve to my non-SCA friends. This was voted best dish of the day, but I disagree... because my favorite was the next dish!

The Applade Ryalle "in need" is a lovely soup with a base of wine and honey. The wine and the apples explode in your mouth on the first spoonful, and then the honey peeks through along with the spices. It was decided that this goes on the "must be served at a future event" list, alongside some good crusty bread, cheese, and smoked pork. Have I mentioned I have great taste testers???

.Cxxxv. Applade Ryalle.—Take Applys, & seþe hem tylle þey ben tendyr, & þan lat hem kele; þen draw hem þorw a straynour; & on flesshe day caste þer-to gode fatte broþe of freysshe beef, an whyte grece, & Sugre, & Safroun, & gode pouder; & in a Fysshe day, take Almaunde mylke, & oyle of Olyff, & draw þer-vppe with-al a gode pouder, & serue forth. An for nede, draw it vppe with Wyne, & a lytil hony put þer-to for to make it þan dowcet; & serue it forth.

Cxxxv - Applade Ryalle. Take Applys, and sethe hem tylle they ben tendyr, and than lat hem kele; then draw hem thorw a straynour; and on flesh day caste ther-to gode fatte brothe of freysshe beef, an whyte grece, and Sugre, and Safroun, and gode pouder; and in a Fysshe day, take Almaunde mylke, and oyle of Olyff, and draw ther-vppe with-al a gode pouder, and serue forth. An for nede, draw it vppe with Wyne, and a lytil hony put ther-to for to make it than dowcet; and serue it forth.

135. Apple Royal – Take apples and seethe them until they be tender and then let them cool; then draw them through a strainer; and on flesh day cast thereto good fat broth of fresh beef and white grease, and sugar and saffron, and good powder; and on a fish day, take almond milk, and olive oil, and draw there up with a good powder and serve forth. And for need, draw it up with wine, and a little honey put there to for to make it than sweet and serve it forth.

Interpreted Recipe – Serves 8

• 6–8 apples
• Water to cover
• 4 cups broth, wine, or almond milk
• 1/3 cup sugar or honey (adjust to taste)
• 1 tbsp. powder douce
• 2 tbsp. butter or olive oil (optional)
• Pinch of saffron (optional)

Today I cut the apples into large chunks and placed them into the pot—I did not core or peel them. I covered them with water and allowed them to boil until tender and the water was almost gone. I then put the apples into the food processor (yay for modern technology) and puréed them, then strained them into a bowl. I used my last seven orchard-picked apples today. If you're skipping this step, use approximately 1 1/2 cups of unsweetened applesauce per 2 cups of broth, wine, or almond milk.

I added the powder douce to the apple purée while hot and mixed it in, rather than cooking it in the liquid base. I omitted the saffron this round.

For each soup variation, I heated the liquid base with sugar or honey as appropriate (honey for "in need," sugar for flesh and fish days). I also added the "grease" — in this case, butter or olive oil — to the flesh and fish day recipes before stirring in the puréed and spiced apple. I cooked the mixtures together until they reduced to the consistency I wanted, then served them hot.

You might think these soups would be too thin and need a thickener, but I suspect that leaving the skins on allowed more pectin to remain with the soup. If your version seems too thin, period thickeners like breadcrumbs, rice flour, or egg yolks can help — just be sure to strain before serving for a smooth finish.

Similar Recipes

• MS Royal 12.C.xii (England/France, 1340): Poumes ammolee – Wine, eggs, wheat flour, and apples, thickened and sweetened.
• Ancient Cookery [Arundel 334] (England, 1425): Appeluns for a lorde – Apples boiled and puréed, with vernage wine, egg yolks, sugar, and rosewater.
• A Noble Boke off Cookry (England, 1468): Appillinose – Apples with almond milk or broth, saffron, sugar, and spices.
• The Neapolitan Recipe Collection (Italy, 15th c.): Applesauce – Cooked apples, almond milk, rosewater, sugar, and spices, served thick.

Apple Moyle - A Sweet Medieval Apple Porridge

.Cxxxiiij. Apple Moyle – A Sweet Porridge of Apples & Almond Milk

Apples belong to the Rosaceae family along with pears, quince, loquat, medlars and yes, roses. It is believed that there has been over 10,000 different apple cultivars that have been developed, many of which are now lost. There are at least 100 different varieties of apples that are grown commercially, but of those, only ten make up 90% of the production in the United States. I find this distressingly sad.

As mentioned in my previous post on .lxxix. Apple Muse it is generally believed that domesticated apples has their origins in Central Asia. Apples are documented as early as 6500 B.C. in Jericho and the Jordan Valley. Theophrastes records in 323 B.C the process of budding, grafting and general tree care of six different varieties of apples that were known at the time.

There are many legends regarding this fruit, the most well-known is that of Adam and Eve wherein Eve tempts Adam to eat of the "forbidden fruit". Apples are well known then, as a fruit synonymous with temptation, a reputation that is apparently well earned.

Hercules is tasked with stealing the golden apples from the Tree of Life as one of his Twelve Labors. Atalanta, was tricked by Hippomenes, losing a footrace and securing a husband, because she stopped to pick up Golden Apples given to Hippomenes by Aphrodite.

Eris, the Greek goddess of discord threw a golden apple into the wedding party of Thetis and Peleus. The apple was inscribed with the word "kallisti", meaning the fairest. Three Goddesses coveted the apple, Hera, Athena and Aphrodite and the task of appointing which of the Goddesses was indeed the fairest fell upon Paris of Troy. It was Aphrodite who promised Paris of Troy the love of the most beautiful woman, Helen of Sparta, if he would appoint her the keeper of the apple. He did, and it was this apple that was indirectly responsible for causing the Trojan War.

Apples were not always associated with lust, love, temptation or sin. In fact, in Norse mythology it is the Goddess Idun who is the guardian of the golden apples that preserved the eternal youth of the Aesir. It is the apple that gave Avalon its name in the legends of King Arthur. The Welsh word for apple is Afal. In the legends of Arthur, apples are associated with very powerful forces of creation, birth, death and rebirth.

Lastly, the ancient Celts believed that apples were to be treasured. Apple blossoms were used as symbols of fertility and would be placed in bedrooms. They were also symbolic of goodwill, integrity and purity and love. There is a myth told of Conle, who received an apple that fed him for a year.

Dietary Notes: Naturally vegan, dairy-free, and easily gluten-free with certified rice flour.

As explored in my previous post on Apple Muse, apples are more than just a pantry staple—they are mythic, symbolic, and deeply tied to culinary history. From the Golden Apples of the Hesperides to Idun’s youth-preserving fruit, their place in mythology rivals their place in the medieval kitchen.

Apple Moyle comes to us from the Harleian MS. 279, and like many medieval dishes, it leaves room for interpretation. My reading suggests a creamy porridge, enriched with almond milk and brightened by saffron and sweet spices. The base is similar to Cxxv - Vyolette, a sweet violet-hued pudding also made with rice flour and almond milk.

🔍 What Does Moyle Mean?

The word “moyle” doesn’t have a direct, surviving culinary definition in modern English, but in the context of medieval cooking, it appears to carry a connotation of softening, mashing, or reducing to a pulp.

It may be connected to:

• Old French “moiller” or “mouiller” – to moisten or make soft/wet
• Latin “mollis” – soft
• Middle English “moillen” – to soften, soak, or mash

In the recipe, the phrase: “...take apples, and pare hem, an smal screde hem in mossellys...” directs the cook to shred apples into morsels and simmer them with rice and almond milk until softened—producing something thickened and spoonable, like a mash or porridge.

📘 Compare to “Apple Muse”

As discussed in the Apple Muse post, “muse” is derived from Middle English and Old French terms for mash, pulp, or purée. Both Moyle and Muse reflect method and texture more than specific ingredients.

• Muse often results in a fully puréed dish
• Moyle retains soft apple chunks within a thickened base

🧠 Historical Insight

These names were likely descriptive rather than fixed titles. A medieval cook might have considered moyle to mean “the soft one” and muse to imply a smoother mash.

If naming them today, you might say:

• Apple Muse = smooth apple-almond porridge
• Apple Moyle = soft apple-and-almond stew with texture

✅ In Summary: “Apple Moyle” likely refers to the soft texture of the finished dish. Like “muse,” it reflects a tradition of sweetened, spiced fruit preparations—served warm, spoonable, and comforting.

Original Recipe – Harleian MS. 279

Nym Rys, an bray hem wyl, & temper hem with Almaunde mylke, & boyle it; & take Applys, & pare hem, an smal screde hem in mossellys; þrow on sugre y-now, & coloure it with Safroun, & caste þer-to gode pouder, & serue forth.

Interpreted Recipe – Apple Moyle

Serves 8 as a breakfast or side dish

Ingredients

• 2 cups almond milk
• 1/2 cup rice flour
• 4 small apples, peeled, cored, diced
• 1/2 cup sugar
• Generous pinch of saffron
• 1 tsp powder douce
• 1/4 tsp salt (optional, but recommended)

Instructions

1. Combine almond milk, rice flour, saffron, sugar, and salt in a saucepan over medium heat.
2. Add diced apples and simmer gently, stirring often, until apples are soft and the mixture thickens (15–20 minutes).
3. Sprinkle with powder douce just before serving.

When was Apple Moyle Served? 

This dish likely appeared during the pottage course of a medieval feast—offered as a soft, nourishing side. It could also be served as a fruit sauce for meat (especially pork or poultry), or as a light first course to stimulate appetite. Leftovers can be stored in the fridge and reheated gently with a splash of almond milk to loosen the texture.

Notes from the Test Kitchen

This dish was a hit with my testers—so much so that there may have been spoon duels over the last bite. I added a pinch of salt, which balanced the sweetness beautifully. This pudding makes an excellent camp breakfast: simple, hearty, and deeply satisfying.

Related Recipes

• Apple Muse – Another medieval apple pudding with rice flour and almond milk.
• Ein Apfelmus (c.1345, Germany) – A richer apple mash with wine and egg.
• Forme of Cury: Appulmoy – Pureed apple with almond milk, honey, and rice flour.